When Therapy and Medication Aren’t Enough: A Holistic Approach to Anxiety and Emotional Health

It can feel defeating to do everything you’re “supposed” to do—show up for therapy, practice the coping tools, read the books, journal, meditate, work on personal growth—and still feel anxious. Many people reach a point where they understand their patterns, can name their triggers, and have real self-awareness… yet their nervous system continues to act like danger is around the corner.

That’s often when anxiety starts to feel less like a mindset issue and more like something happening inside the body. You may notice anxiety showing up physically: a tight chest, racing heart, stomach knots, shallow breathing, tense shoulders, or restless sleep. Even on days when life is relatively stable, the body can still feel braced—like it’s stuck in “on” mode.

Over time, the emotional toll is heavy. You may feel like you’re trying harder just to stay afloat—only to end up exhausted, discouraged, or frustrated with yourself. This is where many people begin to wonder: If I’m doing the inner work… why am I still anxious?

When Therapy and Medication Help—and When They Have Limits

Common Ways Therapy Supports Healing

Therapy can be transformative, especially when it provides:

• Insight and emotional processing, helping you make sense of your history and patterns
• Trauma-informed support, allowing the body and mind to feel safer over time
• Skills for regulation, such as mindfulness, grounding, breathwork, and cognitive strategies
• Practical growth in relationship patterns, boundaries, and behavior change

For many people, therapy is a cornerstone of healing—and it often should remain part of care.

When Medication Can Be Appropriate

Medication can also be appropriate and lifesaving in certain situations, especially when:

• Symptoms are severe or significantly impair daily function
• Anxiety is creating panic, insomnia, or inability to work, parent, or maintain stability
• A person needs support during a high-risk or high-stress season, as stabilization can open the door for deeper healing

However, even when medication reduces symptoms, it may not fully address the drivers beneath them. If the body continues to send stress signals, anxiety can persist under the surface—or return when circumstances shift.

Signs You May Need a Broader Whole-Body Approach

You may want a more comprehensive, whole-body evaluation if:

• Anxiety persists despite consistent therapy and/or medication
• Symptoms fluctuate with cycles, sleep, meals, or stress
• Anxiety is paired with fatigue, brain fog, irritability, or insomnia
• You feel “wired but tired,” with frequent adrenaline surges or sudden crashes
• You’re sensitive to caffeine, experience sugar crashes, or notice gut symptoms that track with mood

These patterns often suggest physiological factors are influencing emotional regulation.

Key Root Causes That Can Make Anxiety Feel “Unreachable”

Blood Sugar and Anxiety

Blood sugar dips can trigger a rapid stress response. When glucose drops, the body releases adrenaline and cortisol to compensate—and that can feel exactly like anxiety.

Common patterns include:

• Anxiety spikes when you go too long without food
• Shakiness, irritability, racing heart, or “hangry panic”
• Feeling suddenly overwhelmed for no clear reason
• Post-meal crashes (especially after high-carb meals)
• Nighttime wake-ups (often 2–4 AM) with a wired, alert feeling

For some people, stabilizing meals and meal timing can noticeably reduce anxiety intensity.

Cortisol Rhythm and “Wired but Tired”

Cortisol is meant to rise in the morning and fall at night. When this rhythm is disrupted, you may feel exhausted at the wrong time—and alert when you want to sleep.

Clues include:

• Morning exhaustion + nighttime alertness
• Trouble winding down, busy mind at night
• Reliance on caffeine to function
• Anxiety that worsens with poor sleep

A common loop looks like this:
poor sleep → higher cortisol → more anxiety → poorer sleep

Thyroid and Nervous System Sensitivity

Thyroid hormones strongly influence energy, heart rate, and nervous system sensitivity. Both overactive and underactive thyroid patterns can mimic anxiety—or intensify it.

Symptoms may include:

• Palpitations, racing thoughts, or internal tremors
• Heat or cold intolerance
• Restlessness, fatigue, brain fog
• Feeling “revved” or “slowed” in ways that don’t match your life situation

Importantly, a “normal” TSH does not always mean thyroid function is optimal for that individual. Some people experience significant symptoms even when labs appear within a reference range.

Estrogen/Progesterone Shifts and Emotional Reactivity

Many women notice anxiety becomes more intense or unpredictable with hormonal transitions. This can be especially true in:

• PMS and PMDD
• Perimenopause
• Menopause

Progesterone tends to have a calming influence through its connection to GABA, the nervous system’s “brake pedal.” When progesterone is low relative to estrogen, anxiety can feel sharper, sleep can worsen, and emotional reactivity can rise.

Gut–Brain Axis and Mood Regulation

The gut and brain communicate constantly through nerves, immune messengers, and neurotransmitter pathways. When gut function is off, the nervous system often becomes more reactive.

Patterns that may track with anxiety:

• Bloating, reflux, nausea
• Constipation or diarrhea
• Anxiety spikes after eating certain foods
• Feeling inflamed, puffy, or “reactive” in the body

Gut inflammation and permeability can amplify stress signals, making the nervous system feel like it’s on high alert.

Nutrient Status and Emotional Energy

Mood regulation requires nutrients—especially those involved in neurotransmitter production, nervous system stability, and inflammation control.

Key nutrients include:

• Magnesium
• B vitamins
• Iron
• Vitamin D
• Omega-3s

Many people try supplements, but supplementing blindly can miss the mark—because dose, form, absorption, interactions, and actual deficiency status all matter. In whole-person care, nutrients are best used strategically.

What “Natural Mental Health Support” Can Include

Evidence-Based, Whole-Body Support (Not “Quick Fixes”)

When people hear natural mental health support, they sometimes imagine vague advice or trendy supplements. In a clinical, holistic setting, it should mean the opposite: evidence-informed, whole-body care that helps the nervous system regulate by supporting the biology underneath symptoms.

That includes:

• Supporting physiology so the body can shift out of fight-or-flight and into a more regulated, resilient state
• Creating individualized plans based on symptom patterns, health history, and appropriate testing—not generic protocols
• Coordinating with mental health providers when needed, especially for patients already in therapy or taking medication (collaborative care tends to be the most supportive and safest approach)

Common Support Pillars

Nutrition Strategies to Stabilize Mood and Energy

Nutrition isn’t about perfection—it’s about stability. Blood sugar swings can trigger adrenaline and increase anxiety symptoms, so a foundational goal is often:

• Balanced meals with protein, fiber, and healthy fats
• Consistent meal timing to prevent crashes
• Reducing ultra-processed triggers that worsen reactivity for some individuals

Sleep Restoration as a Foundational Mental Health Intervention

Sleep is one of the strongest regulators of mood and nervous system tone. A natural support plan may focus on:

• Nighttime routines that downshift the nervous system
• Circadian rhythm support (morning light exposure, reduced nighttime stimulation)
• Addressing sleep disruptors like late caffeine, alcohol, blood sugar dips, or stress hormones

Stress Physiology Tools

These are not “mind tricks”—they are physiological inputs that communicate safety to the nervous system:

• Breathwork patterns that activate parasympathetic tone
• Gentle movement (walking, mobility work, yoga, stretching)
• Nervous system “downshifting” practices that are sustainable, not overwhelming

Gut and Inflammation Support Strategies

Gut health can strongly influence anxiety via the gut–brain axis. Support may include:

• Improving digestion and regularity
• Identifying food patterns that worsen symptoms
• Supporting inflammation regulation when indicated

Targeted Nutrients and Botanicals

When clinically appropriate and safe, targeted support may include nutrients and botanicals that influence nervous system regulation—chosen based on symptoms, medications, sensitivities, and lab findings when relevant. The emphasis is always on:

• The right intervention for the right person
• Safety, interactions, and realistic expectations

Lifestyle Interventions That Are Realistic and Sustainable

Holistic care should reduce burden, not add it. Practical goals may include:

• Better boundaries and recovery time
• Movement that supports regulation (not punishment)
• Social connection and consistent support systems
• Reducing overstimulation (excess caffeine, alcohol, late-night screens, constant stress input)

Calm Is Often a Whole-Body Outcome

If you’ve been doing the work—showing up to therapy, practicing coping skills, trying medication when appropriate—and you still don’t feel steady, it doesn’t mean you’re broken or “not trying hard enough.” For many people, anxiety isn’t only about thoughts or life circumstances. It can also be a sign that the body is running on overload.

That’s where whole-person care can make a meaningful difference.

A holistic approach does not replace therapy or medication. Instead, it complements them by addressing the biological contributors that can keep the nervous system stuck in fight-or-flight. 

If you’re tired of white-knuckling your way through anxiety, consider an approach that looks beyond the surface. You deserve care that treats you as a whole person—not a set of symptoms.

Schedule a Consultation with Dr. Wafaa Matti

📍 By appointment only
Stengler Center for Integrative Medicine
324 Encinitas Blvd
Encinitas, CA 92024

📞 Phone: 760-274-2377
🌐 Website: https://drwafaamatti.com
📧 Email: clinic@drwafaamatti.com
📅 Contact Form: https://drwafaamatti.com/contact

‍

‍