Blood Sugar Rollercoasters: Are Your Hormones Making It Worse?

October 22, 2025

Imagine starting your morning feeling good, then suddenly crashing in the afternoon — exhausted, cranky, and craving something sweet. You grab a quick fix (maybe coffee or a muffin), feel better for a bit, and then… crash again. This up-and-down cycle is what many refer to as a blood sugar rollercoaster — and it’s more common than you think.

At its core, a blood sugar rollercoaster refers to spikes and drops in your glucose levels throughout the day. These swings happen when your body struggles to maintain stable blood sugar due to a combination of dietary choices, stress, sleep patterns, and — importantly — hormonal imbalance.

Picture a rollercoaster: a steep climb (glucose spike), followed by a fast drop (glucose crash). That’s what’s happening inside your body when blood sugar isn’t regulated properly — and your hormones may be the ones controlling the ride.

Many people think blood sugar issues are only a concern for those with diabetes. But the truth is, you can have significant blood sugar imbalance long before your labs ever flag a problem — and it often shows up as fatigue, sugar cravings, brain fog, mood swings, and stubborn weight gain. These aren’t just lifestyle annoyances. They’re warning signs of deeper dysfunction, particularly in your hormonal and metabolic systems.

Your body is designed to maintain stable blood glucose throughout the day, but when key hormones like insulin, cortisol, thyroid, estrogen, and progesterone fall out of balance, it disrupts that stability. The result? A cycle of highs and crashes — energy spikes followed by crashes, intense cravings, irritability, and disrupted sleep.

The Hormone-Blood Sugar Connection

Insulin

What It Does

Insulin is produced by your pancreas and acts like a key, unlocking your cells so glucose (sugar) from your bloodstream can enter and be used for energy. After you eat, insulin levels rise to help shuttle that glucose into your muscles, liver, and fat cells.

When It Goes Wrong

In a healthy system, insulin rises and falls smoothly. But in today’s high-sugar, high-stress, low-movement world, insulin can get overworked. Over time, your cells can stop responding to insulin — a condition known as insulin resistance. When that happens, your body has to produce more and more insulin to get the same job done.

This leads to metabolic dysfunction, where sugar stays in your bloodstream longer than it should, triggering inflammation, fatigue, and fat storage — especially around the belly.

Symptoms Linked to Insulin Imbalance:

Fatigue after meals, especially high-carb ones
Sugar crashes, needing snacks or caffeine to stay energized
Increased belly fat, even without overeating
Elevated fasting blood sugar or hemoglobin A1c on labs
Skin tags or darkened skin around the neck/armpits (signs of insulin resistance)

Insulin resistance often develops silently, but early symptoms can be a clue that your blood sugar and hormones are out of sync. And the earlier it’s addressed, the easier it is to reverse.

Cortisol

What It Does

Cortisol is your body’s primary stress hormone, released by the adrenal glands. It plays a critical role in your “fight-or-flight” response, helping you respond to physical or emotional stress by raising blood sugar to supply quick energy for your muscles and brain.

This response is helpful in emergencies — but when stress becomes chronic, so does cortisol elevation.

When It Goes Wrong

If you’re constantly busy, overwhelmed, or under-sleeping, your cortisol levels may stay elevated. This keeps your blood sugar unnaturally high, even when you’re not eating. Over time, this leads to blood sugar surges, insulin resistance, and ultimately adrenal burnout — where your cortisol becomes dysregulated and unpredictable.

You may go from feeling wired and anxious during the day… to utterly exhausted and unable to fall asleep at night — only to wake up at 2 a.m. with your mind racing. Sound familiar?

Symptoms Linked to Cortisol Imbalance:

Anxiety or feeling “on edge” without a clear reason
Trouble falling asleep or staying asleep
Afternoon energy crashes, paired with a second wind at night
Sugar, salt, or caffeine cravings, especially during stressful days
Weight gain around the midsection, even with exercise
Feeling tired but wired

Cortisol is a powerful driver of blood sugar instability, and it’s often the missing piece for patients who eat well but still struggle with energy, mood, and weight.

Estrogen & Progesterone

What They Do

Estrogen and progesterone don’t just regulate your menstrual cycle — they also play a significant role in metabolism, insulin sensitivity, and appetite regulation. Estrogen, in particular, helps your cells respond more effectively to insulin, keeping blood sugar stable.

When They Go Out of Balance

During perimenopause and menopause, levels of estrogen and progesterone naturally decline. This shift often leads to reduced insulin sensitivity, meaning your body becomes less efficient at processing glucose. The result? Higher blood sugar levels, more insulin production, and increased fat storage — particularly around the midsection.

Fluctuating or low estrogen and progesterone can also lead to increased cravings, irritability, poor sleep, and low energy — all of which feed the blood sugar rollercoaster.

Symptoms Linked to Estrogen/Progesterone Imbalance:

Unexplained weight gain, especially in the belly, hips, or thighs
Increased hunger or emotional eating, particularly before periods or during menopause
Fatigue, even after a full night’s sleep
Mood swings, anxiety, or irritability
Disrupted sleep, especially waking between 1–4 a.m.

This is why so many women in their 30s, 40s, and beyond start to feel like their metabolism has “changed overnight.” It’s not your imagination — it’s your hormones shifting how your body handles blood sugar.

Thyroid Hormones

What They Do

Thyroid hormones — especially T3 and T4 — play a key role in regulating your metabolism, including how quickly your body uses glucose for energy. They also help keep your cells sensitive to insulin, ensuring that sugar is efficiently moved out of your bloodstream and into your cells.

When They Go Out of Balance

In cases of hypothyroidism (underactive thyroid), metabolism slows down. That means glucose clearance is delayed, and insulin sensitivity may decrease — contributing to higher blood sugar levels and increased fat storage.

Even subclinical thyroid dysfunction (when your labs look "normal" but you have symptoms) can cause metabolic sluggishness, which keeps you stuck on the blood sugar rollercoaster.

Symptoms Linked to Thyroid Imbalance:

Cold hands and feet, even in warm weather
Constipation or slow digestion
Dry skin, thinning hair, or brittle nails
Low energy, despite rest
Stubborn weight that won’t budge, even with diet and exercise
Brain fog and low mood

If your blood sugar is unstable and you’re also experiencing thyroid symptoms, it’s time to look deeper. Supporting thyroid function is essential to restoring hormonal harmony and stabilizing glucose levels naturally.

Root Causes: Why It’s Not Just About Willpower

Poor Sleep Disrupts Cortisol and Blood Sugar

Sleep isn't just for rest — it's a vital time for your body to reset hormones like cortisol, insulin, and melatonin. When sleep is disrupted or insufficient, cortisol rises, which increases blood sugar levels, even without food.

Skipping Meals or Eating Too Many Refined Carbs

Long gaps between meals or diets high in sugar and refined carbohydrates cause wild blood sugar swings. Skipping meals leads to hypoglycemia (low blood sugar), while refined carbs cause rapid glucose spikes and crashes — both of which stress your hormones.

Overtraining or Under-Fueling

Excessive exercise without proper fuel can backfire. Intense workouts raise cortisol, and without enough protein or carbs, your body may break down muscle and further disrupt glucose regulation.

Chronic Stress or Burnout

Ongoing emotional or physical stress keeps cortisol elevated, which in turn raises blood sugar and insulin. Eventually, the adrenal glands may become dysregulated, leading to adrenal fatigue and even greater instability.

Hormonal Transitions: Perimenopause, PCOS, Menopause

Hormonal shifts — especially declining estrogen and progesterone or elevated androgens in PCOS — reduce insulin sensitivity, making blood sugar harder to control.

Gut Health and Microbiome Imbalance

A disrupted gut microbiome (due to antibiotics, poor diet, or stress) can drive inflammation, impair insulin sensitivity, and affect hunger hormones like ghrelin and leptin. A leaky gut can also trigger autoimmune responses and further hormonal dysregulation.

Stop the Rollercoaster — Start Healing

Your afternoon sugar cravings, persistent fatigue, or stubborn weight gain aren’t about a lack of willpower. They’re your body’s way of signaling that something deeper is going on — most likely hormonal and metabolic imbalance tied to chronic blood sugar dysregulation.

Getting off the blood sugar rollercoaster doesn’t start with another crash diet or more cardio — it starts with understanding what your body is trying to tell you, and addressing the root cause.

Dr. Wafaa Matti offers compassionate, personalized naturopathic care to help you stabilize your energy, balance your hormones, and feel like yourself again — naturally.

Book an Appointment or Contact Dr. Wafaa Matti Today

📞 Call: 760-274-2377
📧 Email: clinic@drwafaamatti.com
📍 In-Person (by appointment only):
324 Encinitas Blvd, Encinitas, CA 92024
🌐 Website: drwafaamatti.com
💬 Contact Form: drwafaamatti.com/contact